NASA did not provide a direct video feed of Apollo 11's lunar
surface activities to television stations. The broadcasters had to
film it from a television screen in Mission Control. This was so that
it couldn't be too closely examined for flaws. [Ralph Rene]
Mr. Rene notes a correct fact, but then elaborates an improbable
theory to account for it.
First a television primer. A television signal according to the
U.S. standards sends 30 frames per second. Each frame is composed of
525 horizontal lines of information. The signal describes the color
and intensity of different points along each horizontal line. As you
can imagine, it takes a lot of radio bandwidth (data-carrying
capacity) to transmit a high-quality radio signal.
Communications from the lunar module (including the television
picture) were transmitted over a radio frequency in the S-band. This
is a high frequency that normally requires a large dish antenna in
order to send a complicated signal like a television picture 240,000
miles. Apollo 11 carried such a dish antenna, and Apollos 12 and 14
used their big S-band dishes to send better television pictures. But
since Apollo 11 was going to be a short visit, mission planners didn't
want the astronauts spending time setting up the large freestanding
S-band antenna if the smaller S-band antenna on the lunar module
itself would work.
Besides, the world would want to see the first footstep on the
moon, and the only way they could do that is if the television signal
could be "squeezed" into the bandwidth provided by the small S-band
antenna. Neil Armstrong could hardly have set up the freestanding
antenna before taking his first step.
There are a number of ways engineers made that signal smaller.
First they dropped the color information. If you only have to send
intensity information (i.e., a black and white picture) you can cut
the bandwidth by two-thirds. Then they reduced the number of
horizontal lines. This of course reduced the clarity of the image,
but it cut the signal size in half again. Then they reduced the
number of frames per second.
|