| Year | Player | Team | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2001 | BOB HILDRETH | JTeam | The big right hander was untouchable. He has many great years ahead of him. |
| 2000 | TODD ANDERSON | Jammies | Anderson hit 2 homers off of Stone in the Semi-finals and a game winner in game 2 of the Finals. |
| 1999 | BRYAN ALBONESI | The Best Men | Led The Best Men to a 9-0 tournament record. |
| 1998 | PAUL STONE | Blue Thunder | Won his 5th title, and became the winningest playoff pitcher in tournament history. |
| 1997 | DAVID BOFFA | Alien Nation | Won his second title, and showed that he was the big game pitcher everyone thought he could become. |
| 1996 | GEOFF CHASE | Bomb Squad | Won his 2nd MVP award, and showed that a strong bat and an even stronger glove doesn't go unrecognized. |
| 1995 | BRYAN ALBONESI | The New Breed | One of the greatest pitching displays in B.W.A. tournament history. He threw 2 no-hitters, and 4 shutouts. |
| 1994 | PAUL STONE | Bomb Squad | His second MVP award and 3rd Championship. Quickly becoming one of the greats. |
| 1993 | GEOFF CHASE | Bomb Squad | Without his defense, the Bomb Squad would not have won their second straight title. |
| 1992 | PAUL STONE | Bomb Squad | He was a man amongst boys. Would be his first of three MVP awards, and his first of five championships. |
| 1991 | BRYAN ALBONESI | The Batmen | His home run to center field off of Boffa in the Finals may have clinched this MVP award. |
