| Champion | Event | Date Won | "The Phoenix" Miguel Cervantes | Friday Night Carnage | 10/05/2007 | "The Innovator" Michael Gaze | Friday Night Carnage | 08/31/2007 | Asylum | Friday Night Carnage | 07/06/2007 | Ragin' Craig (2) | Friday Night Carnage | 05/04/2007 | Natedawg (2) | Friday Night Carnage | 05/04/2007 | Ragin' Craig | Friday Night Carnage | 04/06/2007 | Natedawg | Friday Night Carnage | 02/02/2007 | Ryan Ford (2) | Friday Night Carnage | 12/08/2006 | Scott Bastion | Thursday Night Carnage | 12/01/2006 | Ryan Ford | Thursday Night Carnage | 11/10/2006 | Angel | Monday Night Brawl | 10/02/2006 | Grunge | Thursday Night Carnage | 07/20/2006 | "The Natural" Sylk Walker | Thursday Night Carnage | 07/13/2006 | Klubber Klabanski | Thursday Night Carnage | 06/15/2006 |
|---|---|---|
| "Red Hot" Rikki Cook | Thursday Night Carnage | 05/18/2006 |
| Dark Tiger (2) | Thursday Night Carnage | 04/20/2006 |
| "The Serial Thrilla" Mikey Lee | Thursday Night Carnage | 04/06/2006 |
| Metalgod (4) | Meltdown | 02/27/2006 |
| Ryan "NuTz" Brown (2) | Thursday Night Carnage | 02/16/2006 |
| Metalgod (3) | Road To Glory | 12/18/2005 |
| Dark Tiger | Thursday Night Carnage | 12/08/2005 |
| Tony "The Bull" Viction | Thursday Night Carnage | 10/06/2005 |
| The Ghost | House Show in Nottingham, England | 09/24/2005 |
| Metalgod (2) | House Show in Oxford, Ohio | 08/06/2005 |
| Ryan "NuTz" Brown | House Show in Newark, Delaware | 07/09/2005 |
| Pitbull (2) | Thursday Night Carnage | 06/02/2005 |
| Terror Soule (2) | Monday Night Brawl | 05/23/2005 |
| Pitbull | Thursday Night Carnage | 05/19/2005 |
| Terror Soule | House Show in Minneapolis, Minnesota | 05/14/2005 |
| Prophet | Thursday Night Carnage | 03/31/2005 |
| Mike London | House Show in Billings, Montana | 03/05/2005 |
| Metalgod | House Show in Verdun, Quebec | 02/26/2005 |
| Drako | Thursday Night Carnage | 02/11/2005 |
| Josh Money | House Show in Pensacola, Florida | 02/09/2005 |
| "The Incredible" Ian Bishop | Monday Night Brawl | 02/07/2005 |
